Celebratory Smoke

RaschNuts
RaschNuts Posts: 882
in General Discussion
So i should be getting my license on the 27th of this month after not having it for 18 months. Ill also be getting a new car since i sold mine when i lost my license. Im looking to all of you to help me decide which one of these to smoke out of the Holiday Sampler.

I have had the Armada and the ESG so its left to these three.
Tatuaje Black Label
Dirty Rat
Olivia V Maduro

Thanks for the Help in advance

Comments

  • rwheelwright
    rwheelwright Posts: 3,294 ✭✭
    Olivia V Maduro
  • wwhwang
    wwhwang Posts: 2,878 ✭✭✭
    Of those three? Oliva V Maduro. But I'd suggest Padron 1964 Maduro or Opus X as well.
  • t_evan50
    t_evan50 Posts: 1,725 ✭
    rwheelwright:
    Olivia V Maduro
    +1
  • RaschNuts
    RaschNuts Posts: 882
    wwhwang:
    Of those three? Oliva V Maduro. But I'd suggest Padron 1964 Maduro or Opus X as well.
    Ya only those three. Dont think i have that padron and my 2 opus X i think im gonna wait till i loose the 28lbs
  • docbp87
    docbp87 Posts: 3,521 ✭
    The V is the only one of those cigars that doesn't currently need more age.
  • Christian_Sapp
    Christian_Sapp Posts: 441
    v maduro is a great stick i would go with it also
  • suneet21
    suneet21 Posts: 52
    I may have to dissent and say go with the Liga Privada. I agree with wwhwang to go with the Padron, but if you don't have one...the Liga Privada really isn't that far off. I've only had the T-52 before from a B&M and it was great...I'd imagine the Dirty Rat to be along the same lines. I'd save the Oliva V for a stressful day for when you are really looking to get knocked out by a cigar and have your knees wobble when you finally stand up.

    How was the Armada and Ashton? i have the same sampler and those are the 2 I have not yet tried.
  • RaschNuts
    RaschNuts Posts: 882
    suneet21:
    I may have to dissent and say go with the Liga Privada. I agree with wwhwang to go with the Padron, but if you don't have one...the Liga Privada really isn't that far off. I've only had the T-52 before from a B&M and it was great...I'd imagine the Dirty Rat to be along the same lines. I'd save the Oliva V for a stressful day for when you are really looking to get knocked out by a cigar and have your knees wobble when you finally stand up. How was the Armada and Ashton? i have the same sampler and those are the 2 I have not yet tried.
    The Armada is a great smoke Nice Spice flavor with Sweet and leather flavors that come out as it goes on. The Ashton i smoked like 3 months ago dont really remember it was good just cant remember much.
  • boydmcgowan
    boydmcgowan Posts: 1,101 ✭
    suneet21:
    I'd save the Oliva V for a stressful day for when you are really looking to get knocked out by a cigar and have your knees wobble when you finally stand up.
    So, I've never had any of these 5 before, so take my advice with a grain of salt. I have had a regular Series V once and I loved it, so I'd imagine the maduro version is a fantastic smoke as well. But I have to agree with Suneet here. Save the V for a day when you really need to unwind.
  • kaspera79
    kaspera79 Posts: 7,250 ✭✭✭
    suneet21:
    I may have to dissent and say go with the Liga Privada. I agree with wwhwang to go with the Padron, but if you don't have one...the Liga Privada really isn't that far off. I've only had the T-52 before from a B&M and it was great...I'd imagine the Dirty Rat to be along the same lines. I'd save the Oliva V for a stressful day for when you are really looking to get knocked out by a cigar and have your knees wobble when you finally stand up. How was the Armada and Ashton? i have the same sampler and those are the 2 I have not yet tried.
    I have that same sampler and I am most anxious to smoke the Dirty Rat . I would imagine the Oliva V is more of a celebration cigar though.
  • gmill880
    gmill880 Posts: 5,936 ✭✭
    This would be my warped train of thought . I would smoke the "Dirty Rat" just to snub those dirty rats that took your license for 18 months !!! Ohhh ... youse...youse dirty rats ( in my best Cagny voice) .
  • docbp87
    docbp87 Posts: 3,521 ✭
    The only reason I chose the V Maduro is that the Rat, in my opinion, needs age. Right now, for me, they are just not quite there. All of the elements are present, but they haven't meshed. That's why I didn't personally rate the rat as highly as the current T-52s. The rats need time to settle. They are just a little grungy right now, but with time will settle.
  • phobicsquirrel
    phobicsquirrel Posts: 7,343 ✭✭✭
    V maddy. A great stick and even better depending on the year.
  • suneet21
    suneet21 Posts: 52
    Good to know...I will let it age for a bit then. How long do you think...3-6 months?

Categories